MY RECOMMENDATIONS

By · Thursday, December 8th, 2011 · No Comments »

I have been recommending various debt schemes from January onwards including investments in GILT schemes on a systematic basis. These schemes were recommended based on some long term strategies which were being followed by these AMCs & have worked successfully even in rising interest rate scenarios. During this period from January to November, RBI raised benchmark rates by 200 bps. Inspite of these hikes, schemes recommended by me have delivered excellent returns based on the strategies which were discussed in my various notes (please visit www.msjcapital.com for detailed notes correlating with dates mentioned below on all these recommended schemes & strategies).

 I wanted to analyse all my recommendations in light of rising interest rate scenario, rising inflation, etc & also figure out whether the Fund Managers’ stuck to their strategies during these difficult times faced by the debt markets. As can be seen from the returns below (point to point from the dates on which I recommended these schemes) both my beliefs in the Fund Managers’ and their strategies have worked out well and generated handsome returns for all my esteemed clients. I had also recommended investment in G Sec schemes thru SIP due to slowing economic parameters & with a belief that at some point in near future, RBI will shift focus from managing inflation to managing slowing economic growth & will offer an opportunity for making some trading profits. When I started recommending this strategy in July 2011, benchmark yield was 8.47% on July 29’2011. It touched a high of almost 9% on November 15’2011 and is currently quoting at 8.53%. Weekly SIP during this period generated following returns:

Birla Sun Life G Sec Fund – LT 29-Jul-11 07-Dec-11 XIRR 11.37%
Birla Sun Life G Sec Fund – LT 12-Aug-11 07-Dec-11 XIRR 12.28%
Birla Sun Life G Sec Fund – LT 16-Sep-11 07-Dec-11 XIRR 18.08%

 

 

Scheme Name
Purchase Date
Current Date
Holding Period (Days)
% Ann Return
JPMorganIndiaShort Term Income Fund
02-Feb-11
07-Dec-11
308
9.50
Pramerica Short Term Income Fund
03-Feb-11
07-Dec-11
307
10.65
BNP Paribas Bond Fund – Institutional Plan
05-Apr-11
07-Dec-11
246
8.92
JPMorganIndiaShort Term Income Fund
05-Apr-11
07-Dec-11
246
9.50
Pramerica Short Term Income Fund
05-Apr-11
07-Dec-11
246
10.29
TempletonIndiaShort Term Income Plan – Inst
05-Apr-11
07-Dec-11
246
9.60
TempletonIndiaShort Term Income Plan – Inst
15-Apr-11
07-Dec-11
236
9.42
Pramerica Treasury Advantage Fund
02-Jun-11
07-Dec-11
188
9.43
Pramerica Short Term Income Fund
27-Jun-11
07-Dec-11
163
9.92
Pramerica Treasury Advantage Fund
27-Jun-11
07-Dec-11
163
9.26
TempletonIndiaIncome Opportunities Fund
29-Jun-11
07-Dec-11
161
9.09
TempletonIndiaShort Term Income Plan – Inst
29-Jun-11
07-Dec-11
161
9.20
Reliance Floating Rate Fund – Short Term Plan
11-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
149
8.96
TempletonIndiaLow Duration Fund
11-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
149
9.32
Religare Active Income Fund – Plan B
18-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
142
8.81
Axis Short Term Fund – Inst
20-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
140
8.00
Birla Sun Life Dynamic Bond Fund – Ret
20-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
140
8.74
Pramerica Short Term Income Fund
21-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
139
9.73
BNP Paribas Bond Fund – Institutional Plan
09-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
28
9.27
JPMorganIndiaShort Term Income Fund
09-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
28
9.61
Pramerica Short Term Income Fund
09-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
28
9.71
Reliance Regular Savings Fund – Debt – Inst
09-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
28
11.17
TempletonIndiaIncome Opportunities Fund
09-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
28
8.23
TempletonIndiaLow Duration Fund
09-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
28
9.34
TempletonIndiaShort Term Income Plan – Inst
09-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
28
9.23
XIRR
9.65%

 

 

MIP/Hybrid/Equity Schemes
Scheme Name
Purchase Date
Current Date
Holding Period (Days)
% Ann Return
Kotak Equity Arbitrage Fund
08-Feb-11
07-Dec-11
302
7.26
Kotak Equity Arbitrage Fund
21-Apr-11
07-Dec-11
230
7.25
Kotak Equity Arbitrage Fund
04-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
156
6.72
Tata Fixed Tenure Fund Series 2 – Scheme A (3 Yr)
11-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
149
8.99
Kotak Equity Arbitrage Fund
26-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
134
6.51
HDFC Monthly Income Plan – LTP
27-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
133
(3.05)
HDFC Multiple Yield Fund – Plan 2005
27-Jul-11
07-Dec-11
133
5.06
Axis Triple Advantage Fund
22-Sep-11
07-Dec-11
76
6.21
Canara Robeco InDiGo Fund
22-Sep-11
07-Dec-11
76
10.85
Axis Hybrid Fund – Series 3
30-Sep-11
07-Dec-11
68
68.60
FT India Dynamic PE Ratio Fund of Funds
12-Oct-11
07-Dec-11
56
(1.81)
TempletonIndiaCorporate Bond Opportunities Fund
28-Nov-11
07-Dec-11
9
0.00
XIRR
8.90%
DISCLAIMER
Topics: Debt Market · Tags:

TEMPLETON INDIA CORPORATE BOND OPPORTUNITIES FUND – NFO

By · Wednesday, November 23rd, 2011 · 1 Comment »

Franklin Templeton is one Fund House which has given solutions at every bucket of the yield curve. All that the investor needs to do is identify the investment horizon of their cash flow and plug it in with one of the schemes of Franklin Templeton keeping in mind their average maturities and exit load issues. Once the investor has done this exercise, the second step is to know the captured YTM of the respective scheme less the expense ratio and they would be reasonably certain of what returns they should expect post their investment horizon of say 3 Months/12 Months/18 Months, etc. If there are rate hikes in the intervening period, returns expectations should be adjusted for this (however still with positive bias on the portfolio returns scenario).

 Most of the Debt schemes of Templeton play on the following 3 stories (combination of any two or three of the stories):


  1. High Accruals (or even low accruals if interest rates are on the lower side) & drawing down on maturities of this accrual
  2. Roll down effect after (after 12 Months, 18 Months, paper becoming 6 Months paper & giving rise to capital gains if the yield curve is even slightly steep) &
  3. Identifying sweet spots on the Yield Curve which offer maximum spreads and future compression possibility

However, TICBOF will play on one more stories besides the above 3: viz:


  1. Bull steepening: going ahead TICBOF will play on one more story which is called Bull Steepening. Yields at the shorter end of the curve could come down more rapidly than the longer end, presenting a better opportunity of capital gains in 1-3 year corporate bond segment

Fund Manager feels that there is no scope for investment at the long end G Secs due to rising interest rate scenario and fear of higher fiscal deficit. Also, due to more demand by Insurance companies, FIIs, Banks, EPFO etc, very little spread will be available in the PSU bond segment.

However, due to following factors, spreads in AAA & AA rated Corporate Bonds in 1-3 years & 2-5 year segment are much higher and can in future give rise to capital gains due to the abovementioned impact of BULL STEEPENING:


Hence, with debt market story panning out as envisaged (peaking of interest rates, lower inflation numbers going forward, lower economic growth & lower credit offtake, etc) will augur well for investing in this segment of 2-5 year corporate bonds and earn very healthy double digit figure returns over next 3 years.

I would strongly recommend to invest in the said scheme NFO with 30-36 month investment horizon as there will be exit load in place for redemptions before 30 months as follows:


DISCLAIMER
Topics: Debt Market, NFOs · Tags: , ,

PARTICIPATE IN EQUITY PERFORMANCE WITHOUT LOSING SLEEP

By · Wednesday, October 12th, 2011 · 1 Comment »

For a long time I have been recommending investing in equity mutual fund schemes either thru strategy of Systematic Investment Plan or Systematic Transfer Plan. Intention of these strategies was to avoid taking SENSEX calls or stock specific calls and create an average which will over longer periods (read 3-5 years) work in favour of the investor.

 However, one scheme which manages to achieve the same objective (of not trying to outguess the market) at the same time manage to cushion the investor from ups & downs in the market is FT India Dynamic PE Ratio Fund of Funds. In the said scheme, an investor can take a call of investing lump sum amount and not be worried on whether he/she has timed the market correctly or not. Strategy of rebalancing between debt & equity based on market PE on a monthly basis will ensure that the investor has higher exposure in equity when market PE is low & vice versa.

  • Please note that this scheme is Fund of Funds (FoF) and will be treated as debt scheme for taxation purposes. Hence, it is advisable to invest in growth option with at least 3 year investment horizon.
  • This scheme does re balancing between debt & equity by investing in Templeton India Income Scheme for debt component & in Franklin India Bluechip Fund.
  • Though this should be benchmarked against balanced schemes, historically, it has outperformed NIFTY over many time horizons & replicating equity returns.
  • Investment Strategy:

IF WEGHTED AVG

PE RATIO OF NSE

FALLS IN THIS BAND

…EQUITY COMPONENT

WILL BE

UPTO 12

90 TO 100

12 TO 16

70 TO 90

16 TO 20

50 TO 70

20 TO 24

30 TO 50

24 TO 28

10 TO 30

28 & ABOVE

0 TO 10

  • Following 3 year rolling return since January 03’2011 TO October 04’2011 which covers the worst period of equity markets (2008-2009) will prove how this strategy has not only protected the downside but generated positive returns over 3 years:

No of observations

182

Max Return

19.15

Min Return

7.52

Average Return

12.25

SENSEX

JAN 14’08

20959

JAN 14’11

18860

Returns

-3.33%#

# as against returns of 7.52% earned in the scheme, SENSEX posted negative 3.33% over the same time horizon. Hence outperformance by almost 11%

  • Current market PE as on September 30’2011 was 17.85 & hence allocation to Franklin India Bluechip is 60% & 40% is invested in Templeton India Income scheme

 CONCLUSION:


I WOULD RECOMMEND THIS SCHEME AS AN ALTERNATIVE STRATEGY TO INVESTING IN EQUITIES THRU SIP OR STP. IN THIS SCHEME AN INVESTOR CAN TAKE A CALL OF INVESTING A LUMP SUM AMOUNT (WHICH SO FAR I HAVE BEEN DISSUADING) & NOT LOSE SLEEP OVER TIMING THE MARKET

*Data Provided by Franklin Templeton MF. NAVs data from Franklin TempletonIndiawebsite & rolling return calculations done by Research Team at MSJ Capital

 

DISCLAIMER

Thank You

By · Thursday, September 29th, 2011 · No Comments »

 


All India  - Fixed Income Category



All Amount – All India No 1

 

 

Topics: Offtopic · Tags: ,

PROVIDING SOLUTIONS – AXIS MUTUAL FUND

By · Thursday, September 22nd, 2011 · No Comments »

At the time of launch of their first NFO, AXIS MF had promised that besides the normal vanilla products, they will come out with schemes which will provide solutions to the investors and ensure that they participate in the right asset class at the right time.

Towards fulfilling that promise, one of the schemes they launched last year was AXIS TRIPLE ADVANTAGE SCHEME:


Build wealth no matter what is happening in the economy

There are obviously no guarantees but you can maximise your chances of making money by investing in a diverse range of assets. By balancing your investments across multiple asset classes you tend to reduce risk of losing money to economic shocks (like the recent global financial crisis). Empirical studies have shown that between 1995 and 2010, if you had invested equally in stocks, bonds and gold, only once would you have lost money i.e. in 1995.

 

Axis Triple Advantage Fund helps you take advantage of diversification by investing in a mix of equity, fixed income and gold in the following proportions.

  • Equity and Equity related instruments            :               30-40%
  • Debt and Money Market Instruments               :               30-40%
  • Gold Exchange Traded Funds                               :               20-30%

This not only helps avoid monetary surprises but also provides opportunity for wealth growth. With Axis Triple Advantage Fund, if you have planned for something, chances are you should be able to get it.

By launching this scheme, they have fulfilled their promise of optimising returns from all the 3 asset classes as is evident from their last one year performance which was 9.3% p.a. as on August 23’2011. This scheme has outperformed all the following asset classes launched over last one year (as on August 23’2011):

  • Outperformed the best one year FMP launched in August 2010 (7.6%)
  • Outperformed the Crisil MIP Blended Fund Index over last 1 year (3.3%)
  • Outperformed the best FD rates of SBI (6.8%)
  • Outperformed the Crisil Composite Bond Fund Index (5.9%)
  • Outperformed the S&P CNX Nifty (-10.7%)

Going forward as well this scheme & all the 3 a021sset classes will do very well due to following factors:


  • Gold is likely to do well due to current US and Euro Zone market turmoil’s,
  • Interest rates are peaking off and likely to cool off in next 3-6 months time & hence ideal time to invest with high accruals and capital gains possibility &
  • Indian equity markets have already  taken a huge beating based on both domestic & global factors, giving good opportunities to Fund Managers in the equity markets

AXIS HYBRID SCHEME:

This is one more innovative idea from the stable of AXIS MF towards fulfilling their promise of providing solutions to the investor thru asset allocation strategy.

It is a 3 year close ended scheme with 81% allocation to debt securities on lines with 3 year FMP. With current interest rate scenario, Rs.81 invested in debt will become Rs.104-Rs.105 by the end of 3 years; thereby protecting the principal sum.

19% will be used to buy 3 years NIFTY CALL OPTION.

The advantage of investing in exchange traded options is that they restrict the maximum loss from equity to the premium paid for the purchase of the option. The hybrid fund is advantageous as it is able to recover all or part of the cost of the premium from the coupon received from the fixed income allocation. This strategy allows the portfolio to participate in equity upside while limiting downside risk.

By paying Rs.19 as premium, the scheme can participate to the extent of 90-95% in equity (unlike schemes which invest 80% in debt & 20% in direct equity & can only participate to the extent of 20% for any equity upside).

Assuming NIFTY remains at the same level or lower over the next 3 years, the scheme will not exercise the option & hence the investor loses the entire Rs.19 paid as premium. However, due to the debt scenario as explained above, the investors will get their principal back with some upside.

On the other hand , if say NIFTY goes up by 50% over the next 3 years, same will be reflected in the performance of the scheme as this 50% upside will be on 90% of the portfolio; thereby generating returns both from debt & by participating in the upside of equity to the extent of 90-95% of the portfolio.


Hence, an investor should consider this as an alternative to Equity allocation & not carve out of debt allocation. With current low equity markets, there is all likelihood of generating decent returns over next 3 years by participating in equity upside thru the call option strategy without risking the principal amount.

They have already launched 2 series of this scheme & their 3rd series NFO is open for subscription till September 30’2011.